A useful failure report lets another maker understand the original problem, repeat the comparison, and see what was actually verified. This thread provides a template for real results; the download contains no invented success story.
WRITE THE CASE IN THIS ORDER
1. Intended result: what was the part supposed to do, and what would count as success?
2. Baseline: model revision, printer/nozzle, material, orientation, slicer/profile, and the settings that matter. Add a clear photo of the failure with its location marked.
3. Evidence: exact error, layer or time of failure, measurements, and relevant redacted log text. Separate observations from your explanation of the cause.
4. One change: record exactly what changed and what stayed fixed. Keep the original project available privately.
5. Comparison: print the same representative area again, document the method, and photograph it from the same angle. Include unsuccessful trials rather than hiding them.
6. Result and limits: describe fit, surface finish, actual time, or the specific test performed. Distinguish an estimate or geometry check from a physical print or controlled load test.
7. Reproduction files: include only models, projects, and photos you have permission to share. Remove API keys, personal details, and unnecessary private paths.
A WORKED EXAMPLE OF HONEST VALIDATION
Our fan-adapter download includes a rendered mesh checked for a closed single solid and the stated overall dimensions. Those checks establish geometry properties. They do not establish mounting fit, airflow, noise, heat resistance, or service life. A later physical case study should report those as separate tests, not quietly turn a mesh check into a performance claim.
Download print-failure case-study kit (ZIP)
Download release checksums (JSON)
The blank worksheet tracks baseline and comparison trials, changed variables, photo names, and remaining uncertainty. Use it as the structure for a reply or your own project thread.
See also how to ask for print help. Specific results, including fixes that did not work, make the next person's troubleshooting much faster.
HOMEBREW / 3D PRINTING CONVERSATIONS
Real print failures and fixes: a case-study template others can reproduce
Practical 3D printing help, settings, projects, and advice from fellow makers.
Print troubleshooting